The objectives of this article are to 1 define the contributions of the comparative public administration to knowledge of governance, management of public services, and national development. This approach was developed by the celebrated anthropologist malinowski and radcliff brown. Now we are going to discuss the meaning of comparative public administration and the conceptual approaches of comparative public administration. Comparative public administration lina miftahul jannah. Sabine kuhlmann, university of potsdam, potsdam, germany and. Public sector management covers such aspects of management as productivity management, and management of human, financial and. The role of the bureaucracy in politics bureaucrats do make policy 3. Evolution of comparative public administration 22 3. Ideally, they argue that one would study management across contexts so that context might be a variable that could be. These approaches are traditionally labeled as managerial, political and legal and they are often overlapped. Comparative public administration comparative public administration focuses on public administration as a field of study and research rather simple execution of tasks. Public policy is the study of what governments do, and do not do. Comparative public policy is therefore simply the use of comparative approaches to public policy. Public administration is characterized by public accountability from which business private administration is free.
This short book seeks to explore some of the foundations of the subject known as public administration, and to consider these from a comparative perspective. Comparative public administration is a subfield of broad public administration discipline. Comparative public policy portland state university. Pdf this is an exploratory, qualitative study of the transfer of public management reform policies and performancebased budgeting from abroad into. From the fifties of the last century the two terms comparative government and comparative public administration have gained both publicity and popularity. Aug 15, 2012 by cleo bonny reading ambassador comparative public administration the importance of comparative of public administration to poor countries in africa and elsewhere are the ingredients such as administration functions, development, history, and structures of those successful countries that can teach you with the management of relations in environmental relations, economical relations, political. Khademian1 in this essay we explore the relationship between management practices and. Partnerships in public service, fifth edition paradigm shift from new public administration to new public management public administration partnerships in public service comparative public policy studies public administration and public affairs public administration nta net pdf public administration n4 pdf public administration pdf public administration.
The complexity of societal problems and growing expectations of citizens for efficient and effective delivery of goods and services to improve the living standard of the people by the government have become a concern. International journal of comparative management ijcm. Comparative public administration, in simple terms, refers to a comparative study of government administrative systems functioning in different countries of the world. Isbn 9789264175006 pdf foreword public and private schools.
The public administration is a part of government and so also the comparative public administration is a part of comparative government. Handbook of public management practice and reform, edited by kuotsai tom liou 93. Public administration in public and nonprofit management. But administration and government are not identical concepts. Public administration in public and nonprofit management m.
The volume editors propose a framework in which context influences the types of managerial actions that can be used effectively in public organizations. Abdul ghafoor awan dean, faculty of management and social sciences, institute of southern punjab,multanpakistan. Comparative analysis of public and private educational institutions. Intercultural management intercultural management is the combination of knowledge, insights and skills which are necessary for adequately dealing with national and regional. Comparative public administration is that facet of the study.
So, according to them, a society has a structure and functions. Financial planning and management in public organizations. Comparative public administration and africa jamil jreisat. In order to clarify this point of view, we shall first discuss some of the existing. Comparative public administration international journal of. Sustainability free fulltext sustainable development. The comparative analysis of bureaucratic accountability thomas b.
Essentially, the comparative approach to public administration has serious inclination to research and theorybuilding. The following will compare and contrast their proposed management models, analyze the contingency model of leadership, and provide insights into the management philosophy of troy n. The term new public management encompasses a wide range of techniques and perspectives that are intended to overcome the inefficiencies inherent in the traditional model of public administration. Read this article to learn about the definition, sources and problems of comparative public administration. Comparative analysis of public and private educational.
Comparative public administration and africa jamil. The systematic and wellplanned management of the affairs of the state to achieve the purposes established by the government is known as public administration. In this comprehensive and engaging volume, otenyo and lind bring together seminal readings in comparative, development public administration and contemporary new public management scholarship. Public administration has to function in its environment which consists of the press, political parties, pressure groups, and so forth. A comparative analysis new public management, governance, and the neoweberian state. Their primary influence has been to pull public administration. Indeed, the character of management action, exerted by the management subject on management object, becomes essential in the course of implementation of a public nature of governance. As a field of inquiry with a diverse scope whose fundamental goal is to advance management and policies so that government can function. The relationship between the state, the state bureaucracy to non. Public administration is the implementation of government policy and also an academic discipline that studies this implementation and prepares civil servants for working in the public service. However, anyone teaching comparative public administration should have this book on the required reading list, for it is a good source on.
Pdf comparative public administration studies the capacity of government and public actors to design and implement policies. A comparative study on human resource management in. Similarities and differences between public administration. A comparative study on the performance of selected public sector and private sector banks in india cheenu goel, assistant professor,management department,pcte,ludhiana chitwan bhutani rekhi, assistant professor,management department,pcte,ludhiana abstract. The statistical data for israel are supplied by and under the responsibility of the relevant israeli authorities. The important points of difference between public and private administration are given below. Comparative management what is it about comparative management focuses on the similarities and differences among business and management systems from different contexts.
Comparative public management argues that scholars must find a better way to account for political, environmental, and organizational contexts to build a more general model of public management. Public policy and implementation in context in this new approach to a comparative text in public management, randall baker examines how, why, and to what extent. Fred riggs, who is known as the father of comparative public administration developed a typology in 19561957 named as agrariatransitiaindustria. Comparative public administration is undergoing different period of reflection, scholars are wondering what the configuration of the discipline really is, and which direction holds the most promise for the future. In this case, the main purpose of public administration is to focus on the achievement of sociosignificant results.
Structural functional approach to public administration. The authors have concluded that ethiopia has comparative advantage in 302 products. Comparative public management argues that scholars must find a better way to account for political, environmental, and organizational contexts to build a more. Agrarian society is the condition of society where there is dominance of agricultural activities. Comparative public administration management study guide.
The use of such data by the oecd is without prejudice to the status of the golan heights, east jerusalem and israeli settlements in the west bank under the. The relationship between the state, the state bureaucracy to nonprofit organizations and economic development. The public administration is according to the type of government. They found that ethiopia has 302 product lines in which it has revealed comparative advantage, rca equal and greater than 1. The study of public administration could be approached from a historical perspective and by looking at the three categories that management administration can be divided into i. The comparative public administration and its rapid rise in popularity opened new vistas of thought and analysis. Comparative public administration focuses on public administration as a field of study and research rather simple execution of tasks.
Handbook of crisis and emergency management, edited by ali farazmand 94. How does it differ from comparative management and policy. The scholarship of public management and administration is located within a transnational, comparative and longitudinal context, wherein you will be exposed to international trends of best practice in public administration over time. More specifically, it is the investigation of what policies are and how they perform policy analysis as well as how they come into being and are implemented policy process. He said, comparative public administration is a new corner to the community of academic instruction and research. It is true that such an established sub field exists in political science entitled, comparative politics or comparative governments. The study and analysis focus on the differences in management styles based on geographic locations. Even though the public management literature has often suggested that management matters for performance in a variety of contexts, we know very little about how the managementperformance relationship is shaped by public or private organizations see the introduction to this book.
Comparative public administration pdf comparative public administration comparative public administration book pdf public administration. These approaches are traditionally labeled as managerial, political and legal. Riggs ideal model in comparative public administration. Zeb khan abstract the problems of collective nature have always received a good deal of attention from politicians, economists, and academicians in an attempt to seek solutions that ensure efficient. Political science department, division of public administration and nonprofit management classroom building b218, 716 8786116 publicadministration. Comparative view of public affairs and management and relationship to the policy process 2. This program prepares individuals for positions of leadership and management in public and nonprofit organizations. Khademian1 in this essay we explore the relationship between management practices and a basic governance dilemma.
The private university has a different reputation and source of funding compared with the public one, leading to different perception and practices toward sustainable development. To what extent is it an empirical system of knowledge development. The comparative approach has been around since the inception of govern ment. A comparative analysis into the age of austerity pollitt, christopher, bouckaert, geert on.
Introduction to comparative public and municipal administration. International journal of comparative management aims to publish mainly comparative studies, but also welcomes general and contemporary research ideas in corporate strategy, finance, marketing, human resources and international business. Deficient areas in chinese publichealth management mechanism as well as challenging issues associated with. Jul 15, 2017 key differences between public and private administration. Approaches to the study of public administration there are three disparate approaches to deal with the basic question of what public administration is. Comparative public administration is a branch of public administration that focuses on comparative analysis of administrative processes and institutions. Khan defined the comparative public administration as a quest for searching patterns and regularities in administrative behavior and action and to characterize them in present day nation states. Public and private schools how management and funding relate. The new public management is seen, like hood 1991 affirms, as a corpus of managerial thinking. Traditional public administration versus the new public. In particular, the analysis includes a number of new and developing countries in an attempt to see where the principles of public. A comparative analysis new public management, governance, and the neoweberian state pollitt, christopher, bouckaert, geert on. Administrative structure a comparative perspective 91 6. The structural functional approach to public administration is a term adapted from sociology and anthropology which interprets society as a structure with interrelated parts.
The perpose of this volume is to subject the comparative field to rigorous selfexamination. Difference between public and private administration with. Key differences between public and private administration. Comparative public administration is that method of the study of public administration which is concerned with making rigorous systematic crosscultural comparisons of the structures, institutions actions and processes involved in the activity of running the public affairs. A comparative study on the performance of selected public. By cleo bonny reading ambassador comparative public administration the importance of comparative of public administration to poor countries in africa and elsewhere are the ingredients such as administration functions, development, history, and structures of those successful countries that can teach you with the management of relations in environmental relations, economical relations. The authors investigated the comparative advantage of ethiopia and the role played by international purchasing. This paper is an exposition into the conceptual and methodological approaches to the study of comparative public administration.
Handbook of comparative and development public administration. Comparative management is the study and analysis of how management differs in various environments. The new public management is seen, like hood 1991 affirms, as a corpus of managerial thinking or as a system of thinking based on ideas generated in the. Public policy and implementation in context randall baker 0275943488, 9780275943486 1994 randall baker 282 pages praeger, 1994 comparative public management. Pdf where comparative public administration and comparative. The new public management is defined as a vision, an ideology or a set of approaches and managerial techniques mostly specific to the public sector pollitt, 1994. Political and policy making bodies a comparative study 68 5.
756 116 279 1040 189 1041 435 1410 716 1304 594 300 181 769 1331 721 1458 1115 901 512 438 249 1428 33 1128 746 406 1351 1254 942 673 281 1507 1132 638 261 420 1110 862 1120 448 767